Panpsychism and Pantheism. An Uneasy Alliance?

Jacek Jarocki

doi:10.18290/rf237102.10

Published : 2023-06-28

Vol. 71 No. 2 (2023)

Panpsychism and Pantheism. An Uneasy Alliance?

Jacek Jarocki

https://orcid.org/0000-0001-8135-6153

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18290/rf237102.10

Abstract

Although panpsychism and pantheism were seen as natural allies in the past, in contemporary philosophy it is widely common to stress differences rather than similarities between them. As a result, only few panpsychists (e.g. so-called cosmopsychists) acknowledge that their view may imply pantheism. In my paper, I argue that at least some popular versions of panpsychism do lead to pantheism. My main argument is that panpsychism meets the minimal requirements for pantheism, defined as a view that the world is identical to all-encompassing Unity and that this Unity is divine. Although there are kinds of panpsychism that allow one to avoid these consequences, the most popular versions of this view pave the way to pantheism.

Many philosophers will find this a serious challenge for panpsychism. On the other hand, it can be argued that this conclusion is not as grim as it seems. An all-encompassing Cosmic Mind has little to do with the God of Abrahamic religions, so it does not necessarily deprive panpsychism of its naturalistic flavor that many find non-negotiable. Be that as it may, the aim of this paper is to turn the attention of proponents of panpsychism to yet another problem they need to solve.

Keywords:

panpsychism, pantheism, cosmopsychism, the combination problem

Details

References

Statistics

Authors

Download files

pdf

Altmetric indicators

Cited by / Share

Licence

This work is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-NoDerivatives 4.0 International License.

References

Brüntrup, Godehard, and Ludwig Jaskolla, eds. 2016. Panpsychism: Contemporary Perspectives. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Buckareff, Andrei, and Yujin Nagasawa, eds. 2016. Alternative Concepts of God. Essays on the Metaphysics of the Divine. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Buckareff, Andrei, and Yujin Nagasawa. 2016. “Introduction. Alternative Conceptions of Divinity and Contemporary Analytic Philosophy of Religion.” In Buckareff and Nagasawa, Alternative Concepts, 1–18.

Byerly, T. R. 2019. “The Awe-Some Argument for Pantheism.” European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 11 (2): 1–21.

Chalmers, David. 2015. “Panpsychism and Panprotopsychism.” In Consciousness in the Physical World, edited by Torin A. Alter and Yujin Nagasawa, 246–76. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Chalmers, David. 2016. “The Combination Problem for Panpsychism.” In Brüntrup and Jaskolla, 179–214. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Chalmers, David. 2020. “Idealism and the Mind–Body Problem.” In Routledge Handbook of Panpsychism, edited by William Seager, 353–73. New York: Routledge.

Coleman, Sam. 2006. “Being Realistic: Why Physicalism May Entail Panexperientalism.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 13 (10–11): 40–51.

Coleman, Sam. 2016. “Panpsychism and Neutral Monism. How to Make Up One’s Mind.” In Brüntrup and Jaskolla, Panpsychism, 249–82.

Coleman, Sam. 2019. “Personhood, Consciousness, and God: How to Be a Proper Pantheist.” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 86 (1): 77–98.

Feigl, Herbert. 1975. “Russell and Schlick: A Remarkable Agreement on a Monistic Solution of the Mind-Body Problem.” Erkenntnis 9 (1): 11–34.

Forrest, Peter. 2016. “Pantheism.” Roczniki Filozoficzne 64 (1): 67–91.

Francescotti, Robert. 2001. “Property Dualism without Substance Dualism?” Philosophical Papers 30 (2): 93–116.

Goff, Philip. 2016. “The Phenomenal Bonding Solution to the Combination Problem.” In Brüntrup and Jaskolla, Panpsychism, 283–302.

Goff, Philip. 2019. Galileo’s Error. Foundations for the New Science of Consciousness. London: Rider.

Goff, Philip. 2020. “Panpsychism and Free Will. A Case Study in Liberal Naturalism.” Proceedings of the Aristotelian Society 120 (2): 123–44.

Harrison, P. 1999. Elements of Pantheism: A Spirituality of Nature and the Universe. Shaftesbury: Element Books.

Hewitt, Simon. 2019. “God Is Not a Person (an Argument Via Pantheism).” International Journal for Philosophy of Religion 85 (3): 281–96.

Hill, Daniel J. 2005. Divinity and Maximal Greatness. London–New York: Routledge.

James, William. 1909. A Pluralistic Universe. New York: Longman, Green & Co.

Leibniz, Gottfried Wilhelm. 2014. The Monadology. In Leibniz’s Monadology: A New Translation and Guide, translated and edited by Lloyd Strickland. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Leidenhag, Joanna M. 2019. “Unity between God and Mind? A Study on the Relationship between Panpsychism and Pantheism.” Sophia 58:543–61.

Leftow, Brian. 2016. “Naturalistic Pantheism.” In Buckareff and Nagasawa, Alternative Concepts, 64–78.

Levine, Michael P. 1994. Pantheism: A Non-theistic Concept of Deity. London: Routledge.

MacIntyre, A. 1967. “Pantheism.” In Encyclopaedia of Philosophy, edited by Paul Edwards et al. New York: Macmillan and Free Press.

Nagasawa, Yujin. 2020, “Panpsychism Versus Pantheism, Polytheism, and Cosmopsychism.” In Routledge Handbook of Panpsychism, edited by William Seager, 259–68. New York: Routledge.

Oppy, Graham. 1997. “Pantheism, Quantification and Mereology.” The Monist 80 (2): 320–36.

Pfeifer, Karl. 2016. “Pantheism as Panpsychism.” In Buckareff and Nagasawa, Alternative Concepts, 41–49.

Roelofs, Luke. 2019. Combining Minds. How to Think about Composite Subjectivity. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rosenberg, Gregg. 2004. A Place for Consciousness. Probing the Deep Structure of the Natural World. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Rosenberg, Gregg. 2016. “Land Ho? We Are Close to a Synoptic Understanding of Consciousness.” In Brüntrup and Jaskolla, Panpsychism, 153–75.

Schneider, Susan. 2012. “Why Property Dualist Must Reject Substance Physicalism.” Philosophical Studies 157 (1): 61–76.

Skrbina, David. 2009. Panpsychism in the West. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Sprigge, T. L. S. 1983. The Vindication of Absolute Idealism. Edinburgh: Edinburgh University Press.

Sprigge, T. L. S. 1997. “Pantheism.” The Monist 80 (2): 191–217.

Steinhart, Eric. 2004. “Pantheism and Current Ontology.” Religious Studies 40 (1): 63–80.

Strawson, Galen. 2006. “Panpsychism? Reply to Commentators with a Celebration of Descartes.” Journal of Consciousness Studies 13 (10–11): 184–280.

Strawson, Galen. 2010. Mental Reality. Cambridge: MIT Press.

Strawson, Galen. 2016. “Mind and Being: The Primacy of Panpsychism.” In Brüntrup and Jaskolla, Panpsychism, 75–111.

Strawson, Galen. 2017. “Physicalist Panpsychism.” In The Blackwell Companion to Consciousness, edited by Susan Schneider and Max Velmans, 374–90. Oxford: Wiley Blackwell.