From Inseparable Operations to the Unity of God: Analytic Readings of Gregory of Nyssa’s Trinitarian Argumentation

Agnieszka Czepielik

doi:10.18290/rf26741.6

Data publikacji : 2026-03-25

Tom 74 Nr 1 (2026)

Od jedności działania do jedności Boga: analityczne interpretacje trynitarnej argumentacji Grzegorza z Nyssy

Agnieszka Czepielik

https://orcid.org/0009-0000-1449-0491

DOI: https://doi.org/10.18290/rf26741.6

Abstrakt

We współczesnej filozofii analitycznej trwa dyskusja, jak chrześcijańska doktryna o Trójcy może być niesprzeczna – jak trzy Osoby boskie mogą być jednym Bogiem. By rozwiązać ten problem, wielu autorów sięga do źródeł z IV wieku. W tym artykule rekonstruuję jeden z argumentów trynitarnych Grzegorza z Nyssy przedstawiony w Ad Ablabium, który wychodzi od jedności działania Osób by pokazać, że jest jeden Bóg. Następnie analizuję współczesne analityczne interpretacje tego argumentu zaproponowane przez Beau Bransona i Williama Haskera. Wreszcie wskazuję na dwa sposoby obrony argumentu przed zarzutami: poprzez przyjęcie albo mocniejszej, albo słabszej wersji tezy o jedności działania.

Słowa kluczowe:

Trójca, Grzegorz z Nyssy, jedność działania

Szczegóły

Bibliografia

Statystyki

Autorzy

Pobierz pliki

pdf (English)

Zasady cytowania

Czepielik, A. (2026). Od jedności działania do jedności Boga: analityczne interpretacje trynitarnej argumentacji Grzegorza z Nyssy. Roczniki Filozoficzne, 74(1), 123–147. https://doi.org/10.18290/rf26741.6

Wskaźniki altmetryczne

Cited by / Share

Licencja

Utwór dostępny jest na licencji Creative Commons Uznanie autorstwa – Użycie niekomercyjne – Bez utworów zależnych 4.0 Międzynarodowe.

Bibliografia

Anatolios, Khaled. 2011. Retrieving Nicaea: The Development and Meaning of Trinitarian Doctrine. Grand Rapids: Baker Academic.

Armstrong, D. M. 1980. Nominalism and Realism. Vol. 1, Universals and Scientific Realism. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Ayres, Lewis. 2004. Nicaea and Its Legacy: An Approach to Fourth-Century Trinitarian Theology. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Barnes, M. R. 2001. The Power of God: Dunamis in Gregory of Nyssa’s Trinitarian Theology. Washington, D.C.: Catholic University of America Press.

Black, Max. 1952. “The Identity of Indiscernibles.” Mind 61 (242): 153–64.

Bradshaw, David. 2004. Aristotle East and West: Metaphysics and the Division of Christendom. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.

Branson, Beau. 2014. The Logical Problem of the Trinity. PhD diss., University of Notre Dame.

Branson, Beau. 2018. “Ahistoricity in Analytic Theology.” American Catholic Philosophical Quarterly 92 (1): 195–224.

Branson, Beau. 2019. “No New Solutions to the Logical Problem of the Trinity.” Journal of Applied Logic 6:1051–91.

Branson, Beau. 2022. “Gregory of Nyssa on the Individuation of Actions and Events.” In Eastern Christian Approaches to Philosophy, edited by James Siemens and Joshua M. Brown, 123–48. Cham: Palgrave Macmillan.

Catechism of the Catholic Church. 1993. Citta del Vaticano: Libreria Editrice Vaticana.

Cartwright, Richard. 1987. “On the Logical Problem of the Trinity.” In Philosophical Essays, 187–200. Cambridge, MA: MIT Press.

Cary, Phillip. 1992. “On Behalf of Classical Trinitarianism: A Critique of Rahner on the Trinity.” The Thomist: A Speculative Quarterly Review 56 (3): 365–405.

Claunch, Kyle. 2013. “What God Hath Done Together: Defending the Historic Doctrine of the Inseparable Operations of the Trinity.” Journal of the Evangelical Theological Society 56 (4): 781–800.

Coakley, Sarah. 1999. “Persons’ in the ‘Social’ Doctrine of the Trinity: A Critique of Current Analytic Discussion.” In The Trinity: An Interdisciplinary Symposium on the Trinity, edited by Stephen T. Davis, Daniel Kendall, and Geral O’Collins, 123–44. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Cross, Richard. 2002. “Gregory of Nyssa on Universals.” Vigiliae Christianae 56 (4): 372–410.

Hasker, William. 2013. Metaphysics and the Tri-Personal God. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Hess, K. M. 2014. “Because They Can: The Basis for the Moral Obligations of (Certain) Collectives.” Midwest Studies in Philosophy 38 (1): 203–21.

Jedwab, Joseph, and J. A. Keller. 2019. “Paraphrase and the Doctrine of the Trinity.” Faith and Philosophy 36 (2): 173–94.

Karfíková, Lenka. 2011. “Ad Ablabium, Quod not sint Tres Dei.” In Gregory of Nyssa: The Minor Treatises on Trinitarian Theology and Apollinarism, edited by Volker Henning Drecoll and Margitta Berghaus, 131–68. Leiden: Brill.

King, D. S. 2022. “To Whom Can God Speak? Trinitarian Persons in Gregory of Nyssa and William Hasker.” TheoLogica: An International Journal for Philosophy of Religion and Philosophical Theology 6 (2): 59–68.

Leftow, Brian. 2009. “Anti Social Trinitarianism.” In Philosophical and Theological Essays on the Trinity, edited by Thomas McCall and Michael Rea, 52–88. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Leftow, Brian. 2010. “Two Trinities: Reply to Hasker.” Religious Studies 46 (4): 441–47.

Leftow, Brian. 2012. “Time Travel and the Trinity.” Faith and Philosophy 29 (3): 313–24.

Marmodoro, Anna. 2018. “Gregory of Nyssa on the Metaphysics of the Trinity.” In Exploring Gregory of Nyssa: Philosophical, Theological, and Historical Studies, edited by Anna Marmodoro and Neil B. McLynn, 220–34. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Maspero, Giulio. 2007. Trinity and Man. Leiden: Brill.

McCall, Thomas. 2010. Which Trinity? Whose Monotheism? Philosophical and Systematic Theologians on the Metaphysics of Trinitarian Theology. Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing.

McIntosh, Chad A. 2016. “The God of the Groups.” Religious Studies 52 (2): 167–86.

Molnar, George. 2003. Powers: A Study in Metaphysics. Edited by Stephen Mumford. New York: Oxford University Press.

Morales, Xavier. 2021. “L’unicité d’opération chez Grégoire de Nysse: une étude d’histoire des doctrines en marge de la troisième Homélie sur l’oraison dominicale.” In Gregory of Nyssa: Homilies on the Our Father. An English Translation with Commentary and Supporting Studies, edited by Matthieu Cassin, Hélène Grelier-Deneux, and Françoise Vinel, 621–40. Leiden: Brill.

Mumford, Stephen. 2003. Dispositions. Oxford: Clarendon Press.

Radde-Gallwitz, Andrew. 2018. “Gregory of Nyssa and the Three Gods Problem: Activity and Etymology in To Ablabius.” In Exploring Gregory of Nyssa: Philosophical, Theological, and Historical Studies, edited by Anna Marmodoro and Neil B. McLynn, 199–219. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Swinburne, Richard. 1994. The Christian God. Oxford: Oxford University Press.

Tanner, Norman P. 1990. Decrees of the Ecumenical Councils. London: Sheed & Ward; Washington, D.C.: Georgetown University Press.

Tuggy, Dale. 2024. “Trinity.” In The Stanford Encyclopedia of Philosophy (Fall Edition), edited by Edward N. Zalta and Uri Nodelman. Article published July 23, 2009; substantively revised August 14, 2025. https://plato.stanford.edu/archives/fall2024/entries/trinity.

Turcescu, Lucian. 2002. “‘Person’ versus ‘Individual’, and Other Modern Misreadings of Gregory of Nyssa.” Modern Theology 18 (4): 527–39.

Vidu, Adonis. 2015. “Opera Trinitatis Ad Extra and Collective Agency.” European Journal for Philosophy of Religion 7 (3): 27–47.

Vidu, Adonis. 2021. The Same God Who Works All Things: Inseparable Operations in Trinitarian Theology. Grand Rapids, MI: Wm. B. Eerdmans Publishing.

Williams, Scott M. 2013. “Indexicals and the Trinity: Two Non-Social Models.” Journal of Analytic Theology 1: 74–94.

Williams, Scott M. 2017. “Unity of Action in a Latin Social Model of the Trinity.” Faith and Philosophy: Journal of the Society of Christian Philosophers 34 (3): 321–46. https://doi.org/10.5840/faithphil20178385.

Williams, Scott M. 2020. “In Defense of a Latin Social Trinity: A Response to William Hasker.” Faith and Philosophy 37 (1): 96–117.

Williams, Scott M. 2021. “Gregory of Nyssa, Conciliar Trinitarianism, and the Latin (or Conciliar) Social Trinity: Response to William Hasker.” Faith and Philosophy 38 (4): 514–39.